At the "Christmas With You" red carpet premiere, Freddie Prinze Jr. was reunited with his "She's All That" co-star Rachel Leigh Cook (per Entertainment Weekly). In an interview on CBS's "The Talk," co-host Jerry O'Connell asked about rumors of a possible sequel to the late '90s rom-com, to which Prinze Jr. replied, "Well, nothing [is happening] as far as I know. However, I mean, Rachel and I almost did something once, but I became a full-time father at the time, so that wasn't going to be an option. But we actually talked at the premiere ['Christmas With You'], and I said, 'this is stupid, we should make another ['She's All That']."
Both performers were set to be reunited in their roles of Zack and Laney in Netflix's 2021 reimagining of the original movie titled "He's All That," but only Rachel Leigh Cook appeared in a new role. In a 2021 interview with People, Cook was asked about her former co-star's participation in the project and revealed, "He is doing really well. We both discussed if he was going to do this one or not." The actress then added, "It ended up not being a good fit for him, but he and the creative team are behind it are totally cool." It seems like the actor is now on board in rekindling Zack and Laney's romance nearly a quarter of a century later.